Buying vs. Renting a Home in Australia: Which is Better for You in 2024?

This is one of the most pressing questions for many Australians today. It’s a significant dilemma that goes beyond just the financials - although this is obviously a huge part. There’s the consideration of where you want to live, your lifestyle, market conditions, your goals and plans, flexibility, opportunity.

It all adds weight to the decision, only made more complex by how rapidly the Australian financial landscape and cost of living is shifting. We’ve put together this guide to help you understand the pros and cons of each option, and help you to better make an informed decision.

What are the basic differences between buying and renting?

Purchasing a home generally involves taking out a mortgage to be able to own that property. First there must be a deposit or down payment - usually anywhere from 5% to 20% of the home price, and closing costs such as legal fees, registration fees and transfer taxes. You also then become responsible for the property, its maintenance and its ongoing rates, taxes and insurances.

Renting a home is a contractual agreement, paying a predetermined fixed rate for the duration of tenancy. You also generally must pay an initial security deposit (bond). You do need to look after the property, but the landlord is responsible for maintenance costs and responsibilities as well as the ongoing rates and fees.

Pros and Cons of Buying a home in Australia.

Pro - Investment & equity: Buying a home is considered a long term investment for many. It is relatively safe to assume the property will appreciate in value over time, providing homeowners with a significant return on investment through equity growth. This equity can be leveraged in the future for loans or used as a nest egg in retirement.

Pro - Stability: Owning a home means it is YOUR home. You aren’t subject to having to move due to ending tenancy agreements or rent increases. This offers a stability that many people, especially families, really value.

Pro - Customisation and improvements: You can really make it your own. You can renovate, paint, customise, hang all the pictures on the walls that you want.

Con - Upfront and ongoing Costs: The initial costs such as down payments, closing fees, and legal costs can be substantial. Additionally, homeowners face ongoing expenses like council rates, home insurance, maintenance costs, and potentially strata fees if the property is part of a strata scheme. These costs require a significant financial commitment and planning.

Con - Variable interest rates: If you opt for a variable-rate mortgage, your repayments can fluctuate with changes in the market interest rates. This can make budgeting difficult as your monthly payments might increase, impacting your financial stability.

Con - Less lifestyle flexibility: Owning a home ties you to one location, making it less convenient to move for job opportunities, lifestyle changes, or personal reasons compared to renting. Selling a home can be a time-consuming and costly process, involving real estate agent fees, marketing costs, and potentially capital gains tax.

Con - Risk of Property Depreciation: While property generally appreciates over time, economic downturns or local market changes can lead to a decrease in property value. This can negatively impact homeowners if they need to sell during a market downturn.

Pros and Cons of Renting a home in Australia.

Pro - Flexibility: Renting offers greater flexibility to move, which is ideal for those who may need to relocate frequently for work or personal reasons. This makes it easier to pursue job opportunities in different locations without the burden of selling a property.

Pro - Opportunity to live in otherwise expensive areas: Renting can allow you to live in suburbs which would otherwise be too expensive for you to buy in to. For example innercity Sydney or Melbourne or some waterfront or beachside locations.

Pro - Reduced Responsibility for Maintenance: Renters are not responsible for property maintenance or repair costs, which are typically the landlord's responsibility. This can result in lower and more predictable living expenses compared to owning a home.

Con - Less stability: Renting can sometimes offer less stability than owning a home. Tenancy is subject to lease terms and the landlord’s decisions, such as selling the property or choosing not to renew a lease. This uncertainty can be particularly challenging for families or individuals seeking long-term security.

Con - No equity building: One of the significant downsides to renting is that the monthly rent payments do not contribute towards building equity. Unlike homeowners who gain equity as their property value appreciates over time and as they pay down their mortgage, renters do not acquire any asset, regardless of how long they stay in the rental property.

Con - Living Restrictions : Renting often comes with restrictions that can limit how you use and personalise the property. Most rental agreements include clauses that prevent tenants from making modifications such as painting, installing fixtures, or altering the layout without explicit permission from the landlord. This can also be a massive issue for people with pets.

Market considerations when it comes to renting vs buying:

The cost analysis between buying and renting in Australia is influenced by multiple factors including property type, location, and both national and local market conditions. It's important to note that this analysis primarily addresses immediate cost differences between buying and renting, without delving into long-term financial benefits associated with homeownership. Factors such as equity accumulation, potential property appreciation over time, and the personal value of owning a home are not covered in this cost comparison. These elements can significantly influence the overall financial benefits of buying a home, making it a worthwhile investment despite the higher upfront and ongoing costs compared to renting in some areas.

According to CoreLogic's analysis, the percentage of suburbs where it is cheaper to buy than rent has decreased dramatically within the past year, due to a combination of soaring interest rates and rental price hikes. For houses, only 9.1% of suburbs are now cheaper to buy than rent, a decline from 30.2% last year. For units, the figure has dropped to 16% from 45.2%.

This trend is pronounced in New South Wales, Victoria, and the Australian Capital Territory, with less than 10% of homes presenting a cost advantage in purchasing. On the other hand, more favourable buying conditions are found in Queensland, Western Australia, and the Northern Territory, where over half of the homes are cheaper to buy than to rent. Notably, apartments often represent a more economical buying option compared to houses, particularly in areas where the rental market is tight and property values remain high

However rental prices are also going up. The rental market has tightened since 2021, with a marked increase in rent inflation across all property types and states, leading to both more frequent and larger average rental increases. Despite high home prices and rising interest rates, future prospects suggest that buying conditions may become more favourable over the next decade, particularly in smaller capital cities and regional areas where purchasing is already more affordable. Conversely, areas like Sydney and Melbourne, where buying costs considerably exceed rental expenses, are expected to experience continued rent price growth..

So, from a simplistic financial cost analysis, it really is highly dependent on suburb and property type as to whether or not it is cheaper to buy vs rent.

The decision between buying and renting a home is highly personal. There are equally important financial and emotional considerations at play. Renting can provide flexibility and a means to afford living in high price suburbs. The sense of stability, security, and personalisation that comes with owning a home can greatly enhance your quality of life and sense of community.

Given the complexity and volatility of the current housing market, having a knowledgeable and supportive partner is more crucial than ever.

IDEAL Financial Group is committed to helping you navigate these challenging market conditions.

How IDEAL Financial Group Can Assist

Whether you’re looking to understand the nuances of mortgage financing or seeking advice on the best areas for investment, our team is here to guide you through each step, ensuring you make informed decisions that align with both your financial goals and lifestyle aspirations.

Let IDEAL Financial be your partner in the journey towards successful homeownership.

Contact Us