Building vs. Buying in 2025: Which Option Is Right for Your Australian Dream Home?

Build or Buy? The age old question when it comes to securing the Australian dream of owning your own home.

Should you build a new home to your precise specifications, or buy an existing gem and make it your own. Is one cheaper than the other?

To be completely honest, one is not necessarily better than the other, and it depends on many factors such as your financial situation, location and the current state of your local housing market. Each option offers unique benefits and challenges that can significantly impact your lifestyle and finances.

Is building or buying more expensive?

This can be very location and market dependent. The costs associated with building a home include the land cost, construction cost, permits and fees, and time. Buying an existing home means the cost is determined by the market price, renovations and repairs, availability and location.

For example, the median price of an existing home in Sydney is $1,055,131 whilst in Perth the median price is currently around $588,068.

The average cost of building a house is based on square metre, but the median building cost in Australia ranges from $611,298 - $1,020,556. Then you have to factor in the land cost on top of this.

However in some locations there may be volume developers building housing in new suburbs slightly out of town, which presents and opportunity for a very low cost build or house and land package which can be a great option for first home buyers on a tight budget.

Other Pros and Cons to Building and Buying

Building a new home

Pros:

Customisation: Building from scratch means you can tailor every detail to suit your needs, from floor plans to finishes, ensuring your new home perfectly matches your vision.

Modern Features: Constructing a new home allows for the integration of cutting-edge technologies and energy-efficient designs, potentially reducing future utility costs and increasing the home’s sustainability.

Government Incentives: In Australia, there are several government incentives aimed at encouraging new home construction, which can make building a home financially advantageous. Programs like the First Home Owner Grant (FHOG) offer significant monetary grants to first-time home builders in certain states. Additionally, there are potential stamp duty concessions and rebates for building energy-efficient homes that meet specific environmental standards.

Less Competition: The market for buying existing homes in Australia can be incredibly competitive, especially in popular areas. Building a home means you're not competing in heated auctions or facing the disappointment of missing out on a property. Instead, you can focus on creating your dream home from the ground up, often on a timeline that suits you better and without the urgency imposed by the traditional buying process.

Cons:

Time Investment: Building a home can take months to over a year, with potential delays from weather, contractor issues, or supply chain interruptions.

Cost Overruns: Budgets can easily expand due to unexpected changes in material costs, plan modifications, or unforeseen site issues.

Stress and Complexity: The building process involves coordinating with multiple parties such as architects and builders, which can be overwhelming.

Location Limitations: Securing desirable land in urban or high-demand areas can be challenging and expensive, potentially limiting your location choices.

Initial Depreciation: New homes may suffer from initial depreciation, where selling soon after construction might not recover the initial costs, especially in a weak market.

Buying an Existing Home

Pros:

Convenience and Speed: Purchasing an existing home typically involves a quicker and less complex transaction process than building. You can move in soon after closing the deal, which can be a matter of weeks.

Established Neighbourhoods: Existing homes are often in established communities with mature infrastructure and amenities, including schools, parks, and transportation links.

Cost Certainty: The costs are upfront and negotiable; what you see is what you get. There are fewer unexpected expenses compared to building.

Potential for Immediate Equity: If you purchase a home below market value or in a rapidly appreciating area, you may gain immediate equity.

Cons:

Compromises on Design: You might have to compromise on the home’s layout, design, and features, which may not exactly meet your preferences or needs.

Maintenance and Upgrades: Older homes may require more maintenance or renovation to update aesthetics or functionality, which can be costly.

Less Energy Efficiency: Older properties may not be as energy-efficient as newly constructed homes, potentially leading to higher ongoing utility costs.

Competition: In hot markets, buying a home can be highly competitive, often requiring quick decisions and potentially overpaying due to bidding wars.

High Costs in Desirable Locations: Property prices in sought-after areas can be significantly higher, potentially stretching your budget. In prime locations, demand often drives up prices, making it more expensive to buy an existing home than to build in a less established area.

Choosing the Right Path with IDEAL Financial Group

Deciding whether to build or buy isn't just about comparing costs; it's about aligning your home acquisition strategy with your long-term goals, lifestyle needs, and financial circumstances.

At IDEAL Financial, we don’t just connect you with the right mortgage options; we help you navigate the complexities of the housing market. Whether you're considering building a bespoke home or buying an existing property, our team of experienced mortgage brokers can provide tailored advice and solutions to ensure your home buying journey is smooth and successful.

When you're ready to take the next step towards your Australian dream home, IDEAL Financial is here to support every decision on your path.

Contact Us